WRTC928

Yes, in concept. In reality, a significant number of people will find it a barrier to entry. Some because they don't want their information in a public database, some because they can't/won't navigate the bureaucracy, and some just because. I've been through similar things before. If you are part of a non-profit, you can certainly give it a try, but I'd be surprised if it worked out

At the moment, I'm listening to someone apparently calling Bingo numbers on FRS/GMRS 19. I have no idea why you'd need a radio to do that. I also can't guess where it's coming from because I live in a very residential part of town. Radio waves do strange things; they could be quite some distance away and conditions just happen to be right today.

It is sort of a shame that there's not a low-cost option for volunteer organizations other than CB, FRS, and MURS. Those are okay if you stay pretty close together, but for some, that would defeat the purpose of the organization. Most volunteer organizations are funded out-of-pocket and the cost of a business license is out of reach. It's not feasible to demand that everyone have a GMRS license as a prerequisite for participating in the organization. But for now, this is what we have.

I recently bought the same radio, and I didn't have any trouble programming repeaters. My best guess is that you're entering something incorrectly. As others have said, post a shot of the file and someone can probably help you.

You guys did me right with the recommendation for the Comet SBB-1. I finally got around to putting it through its paces. It was spot-on all the way up and down the 2m and 70cm bands. The highest SWR I got was 1.3:1 with most of them being 1.0:1. It even did well on the GMRS frequencies, which are technically "out of band" for this antenna, but I'm not going to argue with those numbers. It's on a mag mount in the middle of my roof, which is probably a factor, but the Nagoya was too, and its performance was okay, but not impressive.

Very helpful. Thanks!

I thought I posted this before, but it doesn't seem to be showing up, so forgive me if it's a double post. A friend got a pair of Baofeng GM-15 Pro radios for Christmas and he'd like to program them via software. CHIRP doesn't show a profile for the GM-15 Pro, but I know that many times, the profile for another similar radio will work just fine. Is there a profile he can use to program the radio with CHIRP? If so, which one will work?

Changing the subject a bit, what software are you using to program the GM-15 Pro? A friend recently got a pair and they don't seem to be supported by Chirp, but I know sometimes a related radio's profile will work. Are you using Chirp or the proprietary software?

A friend recently got a pair of Baofeng GM-15 Pro radios, which I guess is a recent addition to their line. There's no profile for that radio in CHIRP, but I know that a lot of times, the profile for a related radio will work. Do any of you know if that's the case with the GM-15 Pro? If so, which profile would it be? Thanks!

The number of people who would know a $20 radio from a $2,000 radio on a TV or movie screen is statistically minuscule. Practically equivalent to zero. They went with something that looked right and was cheap.

I still want to get the TYT software working, though, because there are a lot of settings available that CHIRP doesn't provide. Programmable buttons, etc.

I was NOT looking forward to programming 91 channels manually!

It sees it as COM Port 3, but only if I plug it into the correct socket. Otherwise, it doesn't see it.

Thanks! I went into Device Manager and found that it had the Yellow Triangle of Doom on the port. I then updated it through the Windows system, then I had Windows update all drivers and it came online. Edited to add: It now works with CHIRP. The TYT software still can't find it. NBD, I guess; I'll just use CHIRP.

I'm using a Windows 11 laptop. I downloaded the driver software and ran it. It had a couple of false starts in which it told me "driver install failed" but eventually I downloaded it again and ran it getting "driver install success". The problem is that neither CHIRP nor the TYT software can find the COM port. Am I doing something wrong? Is there some double-secret handshake I need to know? Is there an additional step somewhere to connect the driver to the port? This is the only Windows computer I own. I'm used to using Linux where stuff just works.

I'm hearing a lot more chatter than usual yesterday and today, mostly kids. I guess FRS radios were a popular Christmas present. I give it about a month before they get bored or break/lose the radios. It is kinda fun to hear kids playing, though.

I agree with you about those points, but TBH, they're minor nitpicks overall. It's interesting that the speaker recovered after getting wet. I wouldn't have expected that. Even so, I'm going to try to keep mine out of the rain.

I'm hearing a lot more chatter than I usually do. Mostly it's kids, so they're probably using FRS radios, but one guy 24 miles south of me got something respectable because I can make out what he's saying. Unfortunately, he can't hear me, although I did hear him have a conversation with someone else and he said it's a new radio he's testing. It's possible he has a code set, but he didn't seem to know the guy he was talking to. It would be a remarkable coincidence if they just happened to both have the same code engaged. I'll be interested to see how long it is before the chatter tapers off. My guess is that in about a month, most of the kids will have tired of the radios or lost/broken them and we'll be back to only occasional use. I kinda wish the kids on the FRS radios would stay off 16-22 since they can only use 2 watts anyway, and it's a little annoying that they sometimes jam up the frequencies the local repeaters are on, but I'm sure they don't know any better.

I've commented this to people before, but IMO the 5RM is a better radio than you realistically have a right to expect for $30. I participated in a Ham net this morning on a repeater 22 miles away. I was in my living room with the AR-5RM and a Nagoya 771 dual-band antenna. When I told the host I was on a HT, he said, "You must be using an external antenna. You're really coming in like gangbusters." That's pretty impressive for a $30 radio, IMO. Humorously, when Hams know I'm using a Baofeng, I always have a poor signal. (I'm not specifically bagging on Hams; I'm just saying we're not different from everyone else. You should see how gun guys pile on anyone who owns a Palmetto State Armory rifle for home defense.) I've had a pair of BF-f8hps for several years and a pair of AR-5RMs for several months and I've never had an issue with any of them. I've dropped them occasionally, but it didn't seem to damage them. They probably aren't weatherproof enough for prepper-style "tactical comms", but for ordinary usage, the value for the dollar is outstanding.

I was prompted by @TrikeRadio's thread from July to do a review of these, because his requirement was similar to what I needed. I work with a couple of organizations that do public events, and like most people, I sometimes travel in a caravan of vehicles. For those situations, the ideal radio would be FRS-capable (more on that later), inexpensive, and as mistake-proof as possible. A few months ago, I decided upon the Arcshell AR-5 which I got in a 10-pack from Amazon for less than $12 each. It's a UHF-only radio with a claimed 0.5 watts low power and 2 watts high power, programmable through CHIRP, and with 16 channels. It has the usual Kenwood mic/headset jack and a USB-C port so you can charge the battery in the radio. The battery isn't USB-chargeable alone, but the USB charging feature is nice and it's the reason I went with these instead of some of the similar ones which were a couple of bucks cheaper. Controls are minimal; there's an on/off/volume knob, a channel selection knob, a PTT, a flashlight button and a programmable button which I disabled. I put a drop of Gorilla Glue on each antenna, not because I'm concerned that the FCC would find out or would care even if they did, but if the antenna can come off, some of them will. My friends are horse people, not radio people, and most of them care less than horse droppings about bells and whistles as long as they can communicate. With 2 watts of power and a fixed antenna, they're functionally FRS radios, although not type-accepted. First impressions were mostly positive, considering the price. They come from the factory with 16 pre-programmed channels, and when I downloaded to CHIRP, the frequencies were all over the map. Some had codes and some didn't, a couple were FRS frequencies, and some were in the business band. This is the only thing IMO that makes them less than ideal for the non-radio public -- they need to be programmed by someone who has the software, cable, and skills to do it. They come with the ubiquitous earpiece/mic which so far nobody has bothered to use. The batteries snap in firmly without any wiggle and the belt clips are surprisingly strong for bargain radios. They're light and don't feel particularly rugged, although I've passed them out twice now and nobody has broken one. A few of them have been dropped and sometimes the battery popped off, but they all worked again when the battery was replaced. So far, I haven't had one stepped on by a horse, but no radio is going to survive that, and these are $12. The batteries fully charge in about 3 hours on the cradle and about 2 hours on USB and last 8-10 hours in use. Testing on the Farz-O-Meter 2000 showed a legit 0.5 watts on low and 2.0-2.2 watts on high power. We have only used them at distances up to about a mile, although in April, I'll have a chance to see how they perform at ~2 miles. They are programmable in software for wideband or narrowband UHF FM operation. The audio is crisp and with virtually no static They have only 16 channels, not the nominal 22 of FRS or the (bogus) 60 claimed by Midland, but in practice, we only use about 3 channels anyway. Since 7 of the FRS channels are low power only, I didn't even program them in. I programmed the 15 two-watt channels and a 16th duplicate one using a different DTCS code. The full array of CTCSS and DTCS codes is available, which is nice, because at horse events there are often other people on FRS radios. They have some convenient features available in programming such as "busy channel lockout". They are even repeater-capable, although for my purposes, that doesn't matter. They have VOX, scan, and commercial FM radio capabilities, all of which I disabled. Essentially, I neutered everything except the basic FRS capabilities, but the features are there if you want to use them. The AR-5 is pretty much the definition of "cheap Chinese radio", but for my purposes, they're almost ideal. I certainly wouldn't recommend them for any scenario where life or property would be at risk if communication failed and I have no idea how long they'll last, but at $12, they're virtually disposable. They enable you to talk to other people at a distance, which is the most basic function of a radio, and sometimes that's all you need.

I've had a Ham license for more than 20 days, and I can confirm that the guy is absolutely correct.

Good to know. I was careful to make sure I stripped all the codes out, though.

So...I did get them to work. They're RT85s, not RT87s, but that was a typo; I'm not using the wrong radio profile. On the RT85, in order to enter the VFO mode where you can input frequencies directly from the keypad, you have to turn it off and then turn it back on while holding down keys #1 and #7. After I did that, it took the programming from CHIRP and worked correctly. I can only guess that if it's not in that mode, the frequency numbers in CHIRP don't get read into the radio's memory correctly. I don't know if it played a role, but during troubleshooting, I noticed that the RT85s are extremely sensitive to spurious RF emissions from my laptop computer. If the radio is too close to the computer, it tries to transmit on whichever A/B channel is not selected. That may have been a factor in the data not reading into the radio correctly. I was able to get around that by holding the radio out at the very end of the programming cable while uploading. Thanks for the suggestions. Even though the problem wasn't due to any of those things, you guys at least helped me be sure I wasn't making a rookie mistake.

It would have to be stored on every channel. Besides, I checked that several times.

New piece of information: I put the RT87 and the UV-5R both into VFO, entered frequencies to match, and they can communicate with one another. Apparently the problem only occurs when using channel mode. No idea why that should matter.