I think I have a similar problem. Me and another family member are sharing my call (WRNU678) to do some test transmits through a repeater that we can both seem to hit. We both hear the squelch tone after keying up clearly, very minimal static if any. We are both on the edge of the repeaters range and about 12mi crow flies to the repeater
When I transmit through the repeater on HT1, the other HT2 can hear me no problem. When the other HT2 transmits to me via the repeater, my HT1 squelch breaks on my radio, but I only hear static for as long as the other HT2 is keying up. We had a videochat going while doing this to confirm.
We both confirmed the proper tones for TX/RX were input, so why would HT1 only hear static from HT2 in this scenario?
Thanks!! - Matt
Context/gear the same on both HTs:
HT1
Baofeng UV-5X (GMRS Specific)
50ft RG58 (I know cheap-o but it seems to get out)
Homemade groundplane cut only for GMRS
HT2
Baofeng UV-5X (same as above)
25ft LMR400
Homemade groundplane (same as above)