Problem solved! It was the LMR400 cable! More specifically the connectors. When I was reattaching the LMR400 coming from the attic to the radio this morning I noticed that the connection seemed a little loose, even though it was finger tightened. Nonetheless we proceeded with our test from base to car and got the same results.....not very far. So once again I set up the kitchen antenna and, just like before, we were talking from base to car for miles. So I thought what the he** and I ran the shorter, RG58 cable ( which I was using in the kitchen) from the radio to the attic and connected it to the Sirio Antenna, which was just leaning against a board. With that setup we went 19.6 miles as the crow flies using only simplex, and that was with hills and trees. Obviously it got a little fuzzy and stat-icky when the car was in dense foliage or in a valley but we were ecstatic!