Thinking about getting into DMR.

[UncleYoda]

8 hours ago, Lscott said:

... the digital signals, using the right mode, can fit between the main FM repeater channels

Did you write that opinion paper?  If so, are those preferred modes something that users have to register for like DMR?  I'm against giving some unknown group that authority, which is one reason I would not use DMR on ham.

[Lscott]

9 hours ago, UncleYoda said:

Did you write that opinion paper? 

Yes I did. Yeah, it's not the best written paper I've ever done. Just tried to get my ideas down in some coherent fashion. I'm not an English major. It's easier to just attach it to a post rather than try to convey my ideas a few lines at a time over dozens of separate posts.

9 hours ago, UncleYoda said:

If so, are those preferred modes something that users have to register for like DMR? 

No. The only reason for any kind of registration on Ham is for the user ID's. That's to prevent duplication. However you can use whatever ID you want, but for those that depend on the radio's builtin database it will, of course, show the wrong info.

I had accidentally did that programming one of my DMR based NX-1300's. When I used it one of the Hams on the repeater noticed and asked about it. Didn't impede the QSO any however.  

[UncleYoda]

40 minutes ago, Lscott said:

 However you can use whatever ID you want

OK, I guess I could have tried it w/o registering an ID and see what trouble it caused.  But even then, I'm a staunch analog defender and I hate the way digital modes were allowed to take frequencies from 2m/440.  And I hear some of it on GMRS too even though not allowed.

I don't oppose what you're proposing for ch. 8-14 as they are worthless to me now.  But I wouldn't buy a $150 HT for that.  If they can include it on the $30 radios, then probably so, as long as the radio still supports analog on the other channels as you said it should.

[SteveShannon]

30 minutes ago, UncleYoda said:

OK, I guess I could have tried it w/o registering an ID and see what trouble it caused.  But even then, I'm a staunch analog defender and I hate the way digital modes were allowed to take frequencies from 2m/440.  And I hear some of it on GMRS too even though not allowed.

I don't oppose what you're proposing for ch. 8-14 as they are worthless to me now.  But I wouldn't buy a $150 HT for that.  If they can include it on the $30 radios, then probably so, as long as the radio still supports analog on the other channels as you said it should.

How were frequencies taken from 2m/70 cm by the digital modes? 

[Lscott]

21 minutes ago, UncleYoda said:

OK, I guess I could have tried it w/o registering an ID and see what trouble it caused.  But even then, I'm a staunch analog defender and I hate the way digital modes were allowed to take frequencies from 2m/440.  And I hear some of it on GMRS too even though not allowed.

I don't oppose what you're proposing for ch. 8-14 as they are worthless to me now.  But I wouldn't buy a $150 HT for that.  If they can include it on the $30 radios, then probably so, as long as the radio still supports analog on the other channels as you said it should.

Understandable.

The goal was finding a spot where those that want to use digital voice have a "home", and not impact those who are happy with analog FM. 

The proposed changes allows those who want to continue to use FM won't notice a difference.

The manufactures would have a choice which grade of radio they want to provide. For example right now in the EU one can buy cheap simple analog only PMR446 radios, or spend more money and buy one with digital functions too.

There isn't any reason to force manufacturers to sell only the more expensive combo analog/digital models. The market place will take care of that if the demand is there.

[WRYS709]

2 hours ago, UncleYoda said:

But I wouldn't buy a $150 HT for that.  If they can include it on the $30 radios, then probably so, as long as the radio still supports analog on the other channels as you said it should.

We all want to pay $30 for $150 worth of radio!

If you don’t like digital, we ate not holding our breath waiting for you to use it!