If you are doing it for “the learning experience” then go for it. That is how we all learn best We try things and learn what does and does not work. But consider it like a high-end college education, learning is expensive. For many of us the more it costs us and/or the more we get burned, the more we take away from it. What one learns however is actually quite predictable when it comes to radio since fortunately many have gone before us and have shared their knowledge with the world. Some key things we can predict will be learned. - A high antenna elevation relative to obstacles and receiving antenna are material to extending one’s useable range. - Adding more power does not translate into proportionally greater operating range. - We cannot cost-effectively and legally buy enough power to overcome insufficient antenna elevation. - Watt-for-watt, A home brew repeater will have less usable range in any given direction than operating the same radios simplex. - The average person does posses the knowledge nor the test equipment to optimize the performance of a duplexer and will need to rely on other$ for both. - A commercial-grade purpose built repeater will out perform a home-brew repeater built from consumer-grade components. If, down deep, your real hope is own a repeater that achieves some specific pre-imaged coverage range, here is my recommendation to you. Focus on simplex first. Figure out what it takes to achieve more than your must-have imagined radio-to-radio range. Figure out what type of antenna, how high it must be and with what power and type of radios. Now, once you have figured all that out and are satisfied, then let the repeater enter into the equation. For at this point you can be reasonably assured that you can achieve repeater success with the right equipment. From personal perspective, I do not own and operate a repeater. While I believe I could afford one, I cannot justify the cost of achieving the antenna elevation I need to achieve the coverage I would want to make it worth my while. While some people are blessed to have great access to antenna sites and others have high natural geography to make it viable for them, most of us do not. You may be one of the lucky ones. Whatever you do, enjoy working with radios. They are a great tool to have. Regards Michael WRHS965 KE8PLM