marcspaz

@WRXE944 now you're just messing with me. LOL

I'm not. Never said I was. When was that a requirement to study Law or to help write Bills and ask Congress for consideration? Or a requirement for having a qualified opinion? I mean, I have represented myself in dozens of cases and have never lost. So, obviously being a lawyer doesn't mean they are more qualified to practice law or have an opinion about the legality of any particular issue than someone who has not passed the Bar.

As someone who has spent near a decade studying Constitutional Law, federal law and working at the state level to help draft and propose Bills into law... yes... yes I am.

@WRXE944 that is not how Property Rights in the US work. The repeater owners have zero obligation to anyone (beyond FCC rules and state/federal laws, of course). My house is on a public street. It doesn't mean everyone who has the privilege of accessing that street has any business being in my house and I certainly don't have an obligation to make it known that my house is private, not public or they can just come right in. By law, it is assumed private and you can't come in. Those personal Property Rights don't change depending on the property. You have the exact same 'privilege' to use the frequencies as anyone else. Unless you ask the owner of the radio (which is what a repeater is) if you can use their radio, you can't just assume the privilege of using that person's radio is yours. It is their Right to grant or deny access to their personal property. The problem with you sharing your opinion is, while you don't care if you open yourself to criminal trespass charges and FCC fines, not everyone feels the same way. You are giving out bad advice.

Come on man... you make it sound like if I knock on the door of your house for 20 minutes and you don't answer, I can't just walk in, assuming it's okay because you didn't say "don't come in".

I love this subject. Mostly because I like both for different reasons and because of the responses I get to what I am about to type... Hopefully I don't catch too much grief for writing an unsolicited novel. LOL Bottom line is, on a peer to peer level, if a CB (HF) radio is properly installed and has a proper antenna and antenna installation, CB radio (HF radio as a technology) absolutely destroys GMRS in overall performance. CB provides great line of site coverage; the same coverage as GMRS, but also provides ground wave propagation, sky wave propagation and weaker signal receive capability. Combined, those propagation methods make CB a much better platform. I dare say far superior segment of the Personal Radio Service, due to having coverage inside of potentially 1,200 to 2,400 mile radius, depending on the propagation models used and atmospheric conditions available at any given moment. A GMRS radio, in a standalone configuration like CB radio, will never be able to compete with CB. Sure, there are very limited conditions that occur throughout the year and solar cycles that allow GMRS radios to cover anywhere from 300 to 600 miles, but they are extremely rare and can't be counted on for day to day use. Reality is, 99.999% of the time, you are bound to RF Line of Sight. Depending on where you are, that can be less than 1 mile or as much as 150+ miles. It just depends on your elevation and the elevation of the other station. Now... that opinion is supported solely on the precedent that the CB radio and antenna are of proper quality and installed correctly. The biggest problem that has led many to believe the CB is not good, is the overwhelming amount of trash radios and short antennas on the market, combined with almost never having the system properly installed. Enter GMRS. Again, just my opinion... people getting frustrated with supposed poor performance of CB, pushed a large segment of the 'license by rule' users to look for another option. With GMRS being on the bottom-end of UHF, the antenna installation is significantly less temperamental, making it so you almost have to try to do a bad install. Combine that with the point that the market has some quality radios that can be purchased easily and for a reasonable price, plus FM sounds more pleasant to listen too, and now people start flocking to FRS and GMRS. For more advanced users, GMRS wins over FRS due to the higher power available, the mobile and base station capability (removing dependencies on AA and AAA batteries and improved range) and the fact that we have networked repeaters available in many locations, and now the masses move to GMRS. In my opinion, is GMRS 'better' than CB? No, but it sure is a lot of fun and provides a much easier platform that fills the need to a larger group of non-technically skilled people, making it better choice than CB for many. And that is an important distinction.

Hey folks. I just wanted to take a minute to thank the members of MyGMRS.Com for the support and well-wishes. I know sometimes we bicker among ourselves, but at the end of the day we're all human, trying to enjoy the hobby and help we're we can. All of the messages, emails, etc. have really shown me what a great group we have here and how when someone is truly down, the petty stuff gets put aside and concern for a fellow member becomes the priority. Again, thank you all. - Marc

Team. I have to reschedule this event. I have been in the hospital for a few days and may not be able to do this event for a few weeks. Apologies. Marc

I have 2 different portable repeaters that are made from 2 radios per repeater. One uplink and one downlink. The pairs are literally bolted to each other. I have been doing this with multiple radios for decades and never had desense issues due to the pair being too close to each other. With quality coax and proper spacing between the receive and transmit antenna or a good mobile duplexer and your golden. I've taken the repeater up to the mountains, dropped them on a high spot with solar, batteries and and the up/down antennas separated by about 100 feet. At 20w I was getting 35-36 miles with 70%+ reliability coverage. The real benefit from shielding is in the cable. If you have cheap coax with loose braided shielding, its going to be much more prone to desense and interference in general. Especially compared to something like hardline.

Hey folks. We are going to move this event to Reddish Knob. It is accessible with any road worthy vehicle, has a bit more elevation and has a paved surface at the top of the knob. If you are going to the site from the east (such as from Harrisonburg) it is also about 15 minutes closer than Flagpole Knob. Let me know if there are any questions, comments or concerns.

Wow! Hahaha... I have never seen someone publish wrong information, about such a well-known event, so proudly before! This is elementary school level stuff that you got completely wrong. Well, maybe not completely... there was a woman named Rosa Parks and there was a bus evolved. The similarities end there. Then there's the whole point that fighting oppression and hate has NOTHING to do with following the polite rules of society. You are not oppressed because to play nice with everyone on a specific group of frequencies, you have to use a radio you don't want to, even when it's physically identical to the radio you want to use, but with different firmware. Just not making the connection.

It's me, isn't it? You can just say it's me. I mean, I already know it's true, but I like a good "that a boy" every now and then.

People can hint at it all they want, they will still be wrong. If you don't like the rules, lobby Congress. That's what everyone else who gets laws and rules changed does. In the mean time, you need to live by them or be prepared to suffer the consequences of those choices.

...

That seems like a violation of FCC rules... especially since (I believe) there is no certification process for amateur radio equipment. I'm highly suspicious of them making that claim and having it be truthful. Edit: man... that whole write-up is sus. Dude claims it's GMRS and Ham approved, but you're doing a soft-reset and going between modes via a service menu... now I'm really calling BS.

Wait... does being a VE count? Pretty sure Brian is a VE anyway... but still a valid question. LoL

You're already an extra... stop messing with people. I legit LOL'ed at Our Lady of Perpetual Motion.

I'm posting to subscribe to the thread and to share info about the DC metro area. I'm curious to read updates after the rally in SC. It's kind of strange here. When big events happen in Richmond, DC or Virginia/Maryland DC Metro area, the repeaters usually go quiet. It would be interesting to see how the community responds in other areas.

Welcome! Yes, indeed. Come on out. Everyone is welcome.

I don't use it on my GMRS radio, but if GMRS was my only radio, I would. We are prone to get tornadoes here, so I have my amateur radio set to give me alerts when we have bad weather inbound. Otherwise I leave it off. Man, I love the SARnet. Being in my Jeep in St. Pete talking to people in Panama City Beach and Miami without needing DMR, Wires-x, etc., is pretty awesome. And yes, the abbreviated notifications that a weather alerts exist is a pretty nice feature. Thankfully most of the standalone amateur repeaters in VA also provide that service, too.

Yes, Sir. 100%. Even on the hard trail, you would be good to go. The trail we are going up is a shade rougher than a poorly maintained dirt road. I mentioned high clearance vehicles because there are a few spots that are rutted and a "car" will almost certainly get stuck. Anything with about 4.5"-5" of clearance or more and you will be fine.

Hey folks, I am scheduling a radio expedition up to Flagpole Knob. Lets bring handhelds, mobiles, whatever you have. This is going to be a chance to set a personal-best for range of a contact and soak in some nice fresh air. If you have any non-GMRS gear you want to bring, this is a "let play radio" event. Bring it out. Additionally, I will be setting up my HF radio. Anyone who is interested in trying out the amateur bands and possibly talking to someone in another country from radio to radio, everyone will be welcome to operate my equipment. No need to worry about licensing, as you can operate under my station ID up to the limits of my privileges. No amateur license needed. As a side note, while will we be taking the easiest entrance to the top of the mountain, a high-clearance vehicle such as a stock SUV or pickup truck is recommended. If you don't have one, post up here and we can see if you can ride up with someone who does. This is a "weather providing" event. It will be rescheduled if there are chances of rain and lightning. SATURDAY, JULY 15, 2023 AT 9 AM We will meet at 9:00 AM at the Sheetz gas station in Harrisonburg VA on route 33, just west of route 81, and head up from there. Anyone who plans to arrive at the mountain top later (or earlier), we will be monitoring channel 20 (462.675) while we are there.

Hey folks, I figured I would put this on the books. Lets meet at 3:00 PM at Longhorn Steakhouse in Falls Church / Bailey's Crossroads on July 1st. This is going to be a causal get-together for the group to shake hands, showoff any new toys and gadgets, and chat about radio stuff (or whatever). Hope you all can make it!

@Sshannon I tried that method too. No luck. It doesn't mute or unmute when the tone is present. Mine defaulted to 300, but i tried several times and none of the selected tones worked.

I am totally bewildered by a radio feature and can't find an answer anywhere. I found one single page that says it reduces background noise when there is no audio is present, but that absolutely isn't happening on any of my radios. Hopefully some of the smart people here know what this stuff is. I have several Yaesu radios that have a squelch type called "PR" in the radio menu, and "No-Communication Squelch" in the manual. There is nothing in any of the manuals I have that explain what No-Communication Squelch / PR is. The only thing in any of the manuals is how to turn it on and how to set the "PR Frequency". That's it. Normally, I wouldn't even care, as long as the squelch works. However, no matter what I do, it doesn't seem to squelch anything. Like nothing. It doesn't act as a regular squelch, a reverse squelch, really has no impact whatsoever on how the radio seems to work. It exacts like nothing has been enabled. Does anyone know what the heck PR / No-Communication Squelch is and actually does?