Ok, so I dug the mag mount antenna out and tested that as well as retesting the others. Here's what I got this morning:
Mag Mount: SWR 1.19, 45 Watts
Ghost: SWR 1.36, 50 Watts
MXTA26: SWR 1.10, 46 Watts
So apparently it was the meter or operator error . Needless to say I am both pleased with this morning's results and a bit embarrassed by my panic.
I certainly appreciate you guys helping me sort this out, as well as your patience!