Yes: As noted in my screenshot of the CPS programming above, I did reset them both to WIDE.
Not sure why the CPS allows these changes, if as @KAF6045suggests, these are not to be changed in FRS radios, but WTH!
One will cause substantial feedback/squeal to the other; but in the opposite case: not so much!
I suspect that one of them is just a bit defective; but for $12.50 each, one can hardly expect too much quality!!
UPDATE: Amazon is sending me two more, so I should be able to get at least two "good" ones out of the batch!