one of the things is the UT-72 is a dual band ham antenna. its going to be less good on UHF than a dedicated UHF antenna. I have that antenna and Ive ditched it for a used diamond MR-77 I found for $10.
I bought one of those amps and the first one just quit working. sent it back got and the second one worked but I could barely tell a difference in performance. next to my 50w mobile radio the amp and handheld combined was a FAR cry. I sent the amp back.
I have also gone back to only running my stock rubber ducky on my radio. frankly it outperforms every aftermarket I ever bought BESIDES a motorola someone gave me. That thing is phenominal. I hear comet makes a 9" antenna thats good.
another thing Ive realized is all these amazon brands are like cheap toys. look at real ham brands. comet, hustler, diamond, larson, etc. except for the abbree on VHF those are actually pretty good.
my advice is to send the amp back and get a 25w mobile radio. better yet get a crossband radio that will link your handheld in U-U like a TYT TH-9800, Alinco DR-735T, Wouxon KG-UV920, etc and you can go into stores and whatnot, transmit out to your vehicle, and then to a repeater.