GMRwhat?

[SeaScholar]

14 minutes ago, UncleYoda said:

it seems you are now changing the format or definition to something that seems to be directly competing with this site.

My god man, is there anything that can be done that is not an affront to you?
 

14 minutes ago, UncleYoda said:

If you call your group something like SE Minnesota GMRS Club then we can let it rest as you wish. 

 Thank you for your permission as to what I may call my group/club. 

[SeaScholar]

14 hours ago, ChaosVortex said:

I am going to toss my low watt transmission into the fray here.

(...sic...)

I will speak up when I see any form of gatekeeping taking place into a hobby I am passionate about.

There was a lot to unpack there, but i'm just going to be simple about it and say that there were internal discussions made about the group that were taking place. Anyone that has created any group will always want to start off with something they feel is epic and scale it down. There has been many changes and amendments. For the club, the language was a quick fill and has since been changed to address what the club is about.

Many of the thoughts, concerns, or suggestions you had most likely were addressed in our internal discussions. But thank you for the inputs.

[UncleYoda]

26 minutes ago, SeaScholar said:

My god man, is there anything that can be done that is not an affront to you?

I don't care if you compete; others here will.  I just mentioned it to indicate recognition of the change.  The attitude is your perception.

Quote

 Thank you for your permission

 

was a suggestion

73 to you as well

[WRXB215]

@SeaScholar I doubt I will ever join your club but I'm not threatened by it either. Start your club, call it what you want, run it how you want. It's still a free country and you don't have to justify your club to anyone.

[SteveShannon]

Just now, WRXB215 said:

@SeaScholar I doubt I will ever join your club but I'm not threatened by it either. Start your club, call it what you want, run it how you want. It's still a free country and you don't have to justify your club to anyone.

Exactly!

[WRUU653]

16 minutes ago, SeaScholar said:

Many of the thoughts, concerns, or suggestions you had most likely were addressed in our internal discussions

I believe most if not all clubs on this forum center around having access to a repeater or repeaters within a local area. Perhaps some are just for community of a given area. The point is they offer something that these members would not otherwise have unique to where they are. Your club however differs in that you seem to be suggesting charging for what is already here for free on the very site that already offers it. The old saying regarding business or product “find a need and fill it” comes to mind. Here I don’t see the need. Sure, that’s just my opinion. Perhaps I am missing something and happy to admit if I’m wrong. As a new license holder asking for money for something that exists for free I think you can understand the question of what it is and what’s the motive.

As mentioned above you don’t need to justify to me or anyone else (other than perhaps those that give money) and it goes without saying you are free to do as you like. You may have great motives and intentions. That said when asking for money then questions are valid even if the way they get asked sometimes is not. 

 

 

[nokones]

Will the GMRUS start requiring people to take and pass a written test to get a license?

[SteveShannon]

18 minutes ago, nokones said:

Will the GMRUS start requiring people to take and pass a written test to get a license?

Nothing I’ve read has anything like that. Nor have I seen any evidence that they want that kind of authority. 
But even if they did the FCC would have something to say about it. 

[SeaScholar]

56 minutes ago, WRUU653 said:

Your club however differs in that you seem to be suggesting charging for what is already here for free on the very site that already offers it. The old saying regarding business or product “find a need and fill it” comes to mind. Here I don’t see the need. Sure, that’s just my opinion. Perhaps I am missing something and happy to admit if I’m wrong. As a new license holder asking for money for something that exists for free I think you can understand the question of what it is and what’s the motive.

I would like to point out that the club is not charging anything.. to anyone. That was corrected a long time ago and I corrected it on the club discussion posts. There was at one point a consideration for a "Supporting Member" option, but abandoned because we dont have anything that costs money. yet. and unlikely to change.

[SeaScholar]

23 minutes ago, nokones said:

Will the GMRUS start requiring people to take and pass a written test to get a license?

  - one in every crowd. Doesnt read, and just wants to put their 2 cents in.. i'll give you back your change.

12 minutes ago, SteveShannon said:

Nothing I’ve read has anything like that. 

Yeah, Trolls be living under all kinds of bridges these days.

[HHD1]

Thanks for the entertaining thread.

[kirk5056]

I like the idea of GMRS clubs.  I was drawn here (myGMRS) and to other forums because of the info that was shared.  There are some other forums that I no longer, or rarely, visit because the info no longer met my needs or interest.  If this new "club" interests me I may go there.

 

[nokones]

1 hour ago, SeaScholar said:

  - one in every crowd. Doesnt read, and just wants to put their 2 cents in.. i'll give you back your change.

Yeah, Trolls be living under all kinds of bridges these days.

You must be a genuine amateur and I don't mean an Amateur Radio Operator or are you just a normal developmentally challenged Sad Ham?

[Davichko5650]

4 hours ago, SeaScholar said:

 

We're just a club. That’s it. A place for people who like GMRS to hang out and chat. myGMRS is a great place for people to chat, too. This is just another place, with different tools, if people want to join.

This I can dig, thanks for clearing things up. BTW my post with the "Magazine full of ads" was more a dig at the ARRRRRRL than your club idea. 

 

[WRTC928]

On 8/28/2025 at 12:12 PM, SeaScholar said:

I am not interested in getting into HAM, as I don't see any value or use to my needs or future plans. 

On the contrary, amateur radio is pretty much what you're proposing to initiate. Take advantage of some of the free study materials and get your Tech license. A lot of us participate in both services. They fill different needs.